Deport, depart — KSRM Radio loses news director to visa problem

Photo by Jenny Neyman, Redoubt Reporter. KSRM Radio’s former news director, Catie Quinn, announces her departure on the station’s Sound Off program Tuesday morning. Quinn got word Dec. 23 that her immigrant work visa was not being renewed and she must return to Australia.

Photo by Jenny Neyman, Redoubt Reporter. KSRM Radio’s former news director, Catie Quinn, announces her departure on the station’s Sound Off program Tuesday morning. Quinn got word Dec. 23 that her immigrant work visa was not being renewed and she must return to Australia.

Jenny Neyman

Redoubt Reporter

For the past two years KSRM radio listeners have become familiar with hearing the station’s top news stories delivered in a Down Under accent. But this week, the public safety announcements, political updates, developments in fishery issues and other churn of the news cycle are no longer being conveyed in the unmistakable, rhythmic cadence and vowel-heavy pronunciation of news director Catie Quinn, as her tenure at the station came to an abrupt and unexpected end at the end of last y-EAH.

On Dec. 23, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services informed Quinn her application for visa renewal was denied and she must return to Australia. She was ordered to immediately leave the U.S., the country in which she’s been working and paying taxes, and the Kenai community in which she’s been laying roots and building relationships. She’s got a one-way ticket back to Sydney booked for Jan. 27.

“It was a shock when we got the letter,” Quinn said Monday. “It’s five pages of small print, and the only things I could see is, ‘Does not satisfy … may not be appealed,’ these kinds of words. And I think, ‘Whoa, I don’t think this says what I expected this to say.’”

Quinn has been in the U.S. on an E-3 work visa, which is specific to Australians due to a trade agreement with the U.S. It’s similar to the more standard U.S. immigrant work visa, the H-1B, but it only applies to Australians so the waiting period for approval is significantly shorter and E-3 visas aren’t under the same cap as the H-1B program. The E-3 must be renewed every two years and doesn’t lead to a green card, but can be renewed indefinitely. The H-1B must be renewed in three years and is generally the first step in applying for permanent residency. If a green card isn’t issued, the maximum length of stay on an H-1B is typically six years.

Getting her initial E-3 approval to work at KSRM in 2012 was a breeze, Quinn said, done at a U.S. Consulate in Canada. She first came to live in the U.S. after high school in 2006 on a student visa to attend Colorado Christian University.

“I wanted to go somewhere and do something that really matters,” she said.

She took a weeklong trip to Alaska in 2007 and was immediately enthralled.

“I though maybe I’d like to come back and spend some time here,” she said.

Her student visa allowed 12 months of work experience, so she came to the central Kenai Peninsula and worked as an office manager in 2009-2010, while finishing her college studies in communications online.

Quinn’s student visa expired in April 2010, so she returned to her hometown of Tumut, a small town about four hours from Sydney. She started working in marketing, which morphed into a journalism job at the local newspaper. In the summer of 2011 she came back to visit the peninsula with her parents, who had their first taste of Alaska visiting Quinn in 2009.

“I stopped by KSRM, stuck my head in the door and said, ‘Hey, just wondering if you guys would have any jobs available.’ I had kind of gone everywhere — anywhere, anyone that might have anything going — and no one was really willing to even consider going through the immigration process,” Quinn said.

Photo by Jenny Neyman, Redoubt Reporter. Quinn has worked at KSRM since 2012.

Photo by Jenny Neyman, Redoubt Reporter. Quinn has worked at KSRM since 2012.

KSRM didn’t have an opening at the time, but Quinn stayed in touch, and when a job became available in 2012, the station worked with Quinn on the E-3 visa. First, the prospective employer must apply to the U.S. Department of Labor. Once a Labor Condition Application is approved, the prospective employee goes to a U.S. consulate to apply for the visa.

“It’s a lot to deal with, it’s a lot to have to be a part of. From what I hear a lot of companies choose not to do it just because of how consuming and cumbersome it is to bring on an employee from another country,” said Matt Wilson, station manager at KSRM.

But Quinn has been worth the extra effort, he said.

“She was gangbusters from day number one. She was an influential person not only for our news department, but also in the community when it comes to reporting and bringing the facts out about things happening in our area,” he said.

Wilson said that, to his recollection, it’s the first time the station has hired anyone with an accent to be on the air.

“So there was a learning curve,” in adapting to some pronunciations, U.S. slang and local idioms, for example, Wilson said. “… (But) in my mind her accent was a very proper accent. It was very clean, it was very crisp, it was one that I felt immediately just took the product we put out to another level, with the sophistication in the way she delivers it.”

At the time the position involved some news, some production and some programming, so they listed it as “radio announcer” on Quinn’s visa. This summer Quinn stepped into the role of news director.

“And she has just taken our news department above and beyond where it has been before. She was one of the key players covering the Funny River fire, and this year picked up several awards in the broadcasting community for her news writing and the different pieces that she’s put together,” Wilson said.

But with the letter Dec. 23, Quinn was no longer employed.

“Was it a blow to us? Absolutely,” Wilson said. “You’ve got a really, really valued employee, a hard worker, and literally within a second they’re taken away and there’s nothing I can do about it.”

Quinn said that she began submitting paperwork for her visa renewal process in June, and got a request for more information in return.

“For some reason immigration wanted to nitpick. They are not convinced that this job (as listed as ‘radio announcer’) requires a bachelor’s level education, which is one of the requirements for a work visa,” Quinn said.

She submitted a description of her duties as news director, sent her paystubs to demonstrate compensation in keeping with a professional position, gathered resumes from people in similar radio news director positions around the state and got letters of support from U.S. and state senators and representatives. The supplemental information was sent off Oct. 24, leaving her nothing to do but wait.

“I literally was checking the website every single day to see if they’d made a decision yet, all the time pretty much expecting (they would approve it). The first time I went through this it was so simple. They took one look at me, they took one look at my papers — they didn’t even go through my stack of papers — and said, ‘Yeah, go ahead,’” she said.

But not this time. As she was leaving work Dec. 23 the office manager gave her the letter from immigration, saying her visa renewal had been denied, the decision was not open to appeal and she was to leave the country immediately. That spurred an immediate panic.

“I got in my car and was driving across Bridge Access (Road in Kenai) and just broke down, ‘Oh my gosh! This is not what I expected. This is not what I saw coming. I have to go back to Australia. I don’t know how soon. It says immediately, does that mean I have to book my flight tonight? Surely they can’t mean that! I have to pack my things. I don’t have anywhere to go. I don’t have any job to go to. I haven’t collected my last paycheck. My parents are here!’” she said.

Indeed, her parents, Peter, a chaplain, and Margaret Quinn, followed their daughter to Kenai in 2012. They returned to Sydney to complete their visa renewal at the consulate though the U.S. Department of State this year.

Quinn elected to save the not-inconsequential time and expense of travel, stay in Kenai and submit her renewal through the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.

“And it seems like U.S. CIS likes to nitpick what the Department of State does, I’ve been told, as kind of a check and balance,” she said.

Quinn’s parents’ visa renewal was approved, while hers was not, so Quinn will leave them behind, as well.

“It is devastating. I’ve never cried so hard as I cried after I got that letter,” she said. “Friendships I’ve had for seven years, people who have invested more in my life than I ever expected. My family is here. Suddenly, the only contact I may have with them is email and Skype.”

Her father consulted an immigration attorney, while Quinn sought help from Alaska’s Congressional delegation — no easy task over the Christmas holiday. Staffers from Congressman Don Young’s office and the attorney said the same thing — there’s nothing to be done.

Well, nothing Quinn would actually consider doing.

“The advice I’ve gotten from everyone, from the U.S. CIS office in Anchorage to immigration attorneys, I’m not even kidding you, is, ‘Get married. That’s the only way.’ It’s not even a joke. I’ve stopped laughing now when people say that. I’ve stopped blushing when people say, ‘Well, I’ll marry you.’ And some of them are already married,” she said.

No, Quinn isn’t recruiting suitors.

“It really is about the only way, but I’m not about fooling the government. I just want to present myself and say, ‘I’m somebody who really wants to build my community and this country. I want to be honest, I want to pay my taxes, I’d love to vote. But in the meantime, just let me do whatever I can do to be here. And if you tell me to go, I will go,’” she said.

“She is a respectable person that is contributing to society, paying their taxes, she’s doing everything that she should be doing, and now she’s being deported. How does that make any sense?” Wilson said.

It’s particularly frustrating for Quinn against the backdrop of the current national politics of immigration, given President Obama’s executive order that would grant temporary relief from deportation to some undocumented immigrants.

“I’d love to see this country develop an immigration system based on character and based on people who really want to be here and how they will contribute and have evidence of how they’re going to do that,” Quinn said. “They’re about to let however many millions of illegals come out of the shadows. That’s wonderful, but what about those of us who really do want to contribute to this place and who want to pay our taxes and who want to keep everything legitimate — and there’s no path to the future for me?”

Quinn plans to return to Australia as directed. She will stay with a childhood friend’s parents to start with and look for work. But her first stop will be at the consulate to apply for another visa, as news director at KSRM. The station is currently accepting applications for the position, and plans to hold it open for 60 days.

“I’m going to start the process all over again. I refiled my paperwork with the Department of Labor. If that’s approved I will take it with me to U.S. Consulate in Sydney and reapply all over again from the beginning, and I will have to explain to them why I was denied, and why I want to be here and why they can trust that I’ll leave when I’m supposed to leave,” she said. “I will always abide by the laws of this country and immigration. I absolutely will because of character. I’m not going to hide out in the backwoods of Nikiski. But my heart is in Alaska. If they say I have to go, then I will go.”

But she won’t like it.

“I pay my taxes, I pay Social Security, I pay Medicaid — I can’t claim any of that. I don’t get a (Alaska Permanent Fund dividend). I’m reporting on politics every day, but I can’t vote and I can’t run for office,” she said. “It’s kind of a constant reminder for me — it’s a privilege to be here but there’s a lot of things I can’t do. Sure that’s frustrating, because I want to be here. I want to be part of this community. I love this place.”

12 Comments

Filed under community

12 responses to “Deport, depart — KSRM Radio loses news director to visa problem

  1. Steve Wright

    Give Em Hell Catie ! Don’t give up ! Keep Trying !

    • Poncho Villa

      This is astounding to me. They made this honest, intelligent, hard working girl, who is tough enough to make it in Alaska, and kicked her out of the USA for actually being educated and having a job?

      I have an idea, Catie. Just fly down to Tijuana, Mexico and walk across the border to the US with the parade of 5 million illegal aliens. Just tell them you are a displaced immigrant child (The US Government defines “immigrant child” as being up to 36 years old)

      They’ll immediately sign you up for a social security number, give you some spending cash, free housing vouchers, free healthcare and an EBT card. I’m sure if you ask, they will even buy you a ticket to fly back to Alaska!

  2. Casey Madden

    What a crock…they are pouring across the border “illegally” from Mexico…they arnt paying taxes, alot on federal and state aide and Obama wants to grant a gazillion free pass cards and our Katie cant work here and contribute??!!!! Bu then again Katie it appears you really like it here and contribute a lot to the Kenai so have you considered citizenship?

    • Shannon

      It is indeed frustrating. One of the provisions in the immigrant reform bill that has been sitting in the House for months (and which probably has bipartisan support) is to make way for productive people like this young lady to have an easier path. Boehner won’t bring it to a vote because he doesn’t want Obama to get credit for immigration reform. The specific Latino immigrants to whom Obama granted what is actually only a temporary deferment from deportation pending the passage of a more comprehensive bill, would probably also qualify under that bill (it is not the flat-out amnesty Reagan granted to 3 million of them). These have to meet very specific requirements, including having to have been here before 2007 (or 08?), pay taxes, undergo a criminal background check, etc. He took the working immigrants out of the deportation line (which is backed up by about 300,000 people) to make room for gangbangers and other criminals, whom he has been deporting at double the rate Bush did. In fact, the reason so many more illegals got through recently to begin with was that as soon as Bush was elected, he got rid of the safeguards that Clinton had put into place, i.e., Clinton had started making every employer check birth certificate and/or passports, plus Social Security cards, even for current employees and keep copies of them on file. Clinton prosecuted over 200 employers or illegal hirings. Bush prosecuted only about 15. He even tried to set up the “guest worker program” to allow seasonal workers to come over here to undercut unionized agricultural workers. But now we have e-verify, which Obama has been trying to make mandatory for employers to use as part of his immigration reform, and wants them to keep a copy of their e-verify form for every employee, to show they ran that person through the system to ensure they were legal. But employers are fighting Obama on it because they like the cheap labor. At least this deferment will allow legal employment, which means it will protect American jobs. Employers cannot afford to risk hiring an immigrant under the table who is able to go the Labor Board afterward for all the back pay and get the employer fined. So if employers now have to pay an immigrant and an American the same rate, they will likely hire an American. Their motive to hire illegals is gone if they can no longer get them for less than minimum wage. If they find it harder to get a job, they will leave. Isn’t that what Romney wanted anyway, “self-deportation?” So it was Bush who is responsible for the flood of them during his administration, and it was Bush who signed the law that all those unaccompanied minors from Latin America had to be allowed into the country. I believe he signed it during his last year in office. So it’s ironic that all those people out there protesting the recent influx of thousands of those kids are mostly the people who voted for Bush. Obama even warned them not to expect automatic amnesty, and that most would not qualify for asylum and would be sent back.

  3. Paul

    Disgusting. Obama’s admin allows millions to stay who came here illegally.

  4. Danny Smith

    Just one question. Why didn’t she start the process to become a US citizen long ago? Trusting the government to renew your work visa isn’t a good idea and unfortunately has led to an unpopular decision.
    There are ten steps listed on the US Citizenship and Immigration Services website:
    Step 1. Determine if you are already a U.S. citizen.
    Step 2. Determine if you are eligible to become a U.S. citizen.
    Step 3. Prepare your Form N-400, Application for Naturalization.
    Step 4. Submit your Form N-400, Application for Naturalization.
    Step 5. Go to the biometrics appointment, if applicable.
    Step 6. Complete the interview.
    Step 7. Receive a decision from USCIS on your Form N-400, Application for Naturalization.
    Step 8. Receive a notice to take the Oath of Allegiance.
    Step 9. Take the Oath of Allegiance to the United States.
    Step 10. Understanding U.S. citizenship.

    It’s sad that people who enter the US and become productive members of society are told to leave when other States are being told by the Federal Government they must allow illegals to have a driver’s license.

    • Shannon

      Good points and a helpful list. I used to do paralegal work for an immigration attorney who specialized in getting “B” list entertainers into the country to work (“A” listers are a whole different thing). It is a multi-step process requiring amassing a package of backup material, indexed and presented to Immigration. It includes written work offers here, why the entertainer is unique, the person’s work background in their home country, media clippings, etc. Doesn’t sound as if these steps were properly undertaken in this situation, from what I read. However, on the topic of driver’s licenses, the reason is so they are not driving here illegally without insurance. We end up paying so much for uninsured motorists coverage. Also, they have to read the driving manual (which is also in Spanish) to get the license. So they will at least understand more road signs and the rules of the road, since they are going to drive anyway. This also means they have to have a registered and insured car. California won’t register their vehicle without proof of insurance, which they couldn’t get until they had a license. As counter intuitive as it seems, it actually protects Americans.

  5. jose`

    meanwhile, kingbama grants amnesty to millions of mexicans

    • Shannon

      No, it was not amnesty AT ALL. It was Reagan who granted flat-out amnesty to 3 million immigrants. All Obama gave was a temporary deferment from deportation, and only to that select group who would probably qualify anyway under the bipartisan immigration bill that has been sitting in the House for months. Boehner knows it will probably pass and won’t bring it to a vote in order to keep Obama from getting credit for immigration reform. So in the meantime, Obama took the working immigrants out of the deportation line to make room for those with criminal records. No reason to break up families who probably qualify to stay under that bill (which will pass eventually), and instead leave armed gang bangers loose on the street. Those who are allowed to stay must meet very strict requirements, including paying taxes, and it is definitely not amnesty. It’s just that the deportation line is backed up by about 300,000 people, so it’s more important to get those with criminal records out of here. Obama has in fact already deported about double the number Bush deported in all 8 of Bush’s years. Obama also put them through the formal deportation process, including fingerprinting, so if they hop back over the border, they are automatic felons. Bush merely returned a lot of them to the border without making any record, and they just came right back over. That bipartisan bill also will make it easier for people like this young woman who contribute value to stay. Obama and Biden have been saying our deportation process is illogical, that we educate people here and then deport them when they would be of value to the U.S. The woman who is the subject of this article is such a person.

  6. Colin Nunn

    Thoroughly disgusting!! Illegals flood in by the thousands unchecked and supported, yet spend hods of cash, jump through hoops, put yourself under the microscope to be stripped bare and scrutinized, get a job properly and legally and pay taxes and BOOM you’re out the door! Stupid, inane, insane, crazy, pathetic, idiotic, ludicrous! This isn’t the first time by a long chalk but I never cease to be amazed at the injustice and stupidity.

    • Shannon

      Bush removed all the safeguards Clinton had put into place to make employers stop hiring illegals, like making all employees show passports or birth certificates and a Social Security card. Employers had to make copies and keep them on file, along with a signed W-9 form for each employee, even long term employees. I was born here, and of obvious Anglo/Eastern European descent, and yet I had to provide that everywhere I worked (I was free-lancing at the time). Then Clinton also prosecuted over 200 companies for hiring illegals. Bush got into office, stopped making employers check for legal status of their employees, and further only prosecuted about 15 employers for hiring illegals. So we know who really wants that cheap labor, don’t we? One of the things Obama has been demanding is that, since we now have e-verify available to check legal status, that all employers be required to use it and to keep a copy of proof of their e-verify form for every employee. But the Republican governor of Arizona refused to even put that requirement into Arizona’s law because so many businessmen whose support she needed to be re-elected had lobbied against it so they could keep that revolving door of cheap illegal labor open. Then she blamed Obama for all the immigrants flooding into Arizona. My father was a career U.S. Border Patrol agent, and we spent years stationed in southern Arizona. It is exactly that, a revolving door. So many ranchers run their ranches year-round with illegal help. The Border Patrol comes to get them, and then the ranchers just hire a new crop, and on and on it goes. No prosecution of any of those employers (until Clinton, that is, but Bush put a quick stop to those prosecutions when he got into office).

  7. Bad Bob

    Catie is honorable and appears to follow the law. This will work for her advantage in the future. We will miss you, yet I hope for your return.
    You have earned a place in our hearts and our homes.

    Take care, be well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s